We Are A Mirror

I used to write an improv newsletter twice a month.

I used to improvise, on stage, a couple times a week!

I was in a group called Trail Mix that did 3-person monoscenes, a group called Book Club that did hour+ genre narratives, and a group called BLOODCUP that did ... god, I dunno. We wore black outfits and makeup and improvised based on existential dread and raw emotional truths.

I had a dream about improv the other night. I was onstage introducing an improv-in-the-dark set -- kind of like an improvised radio play, where the improvisors are onstage, the lights are off, and the audience can only listen and imagine -- and I kind of woke up in the middle. But in my eyes-still-closed, knowing-I'm-awake state, I kept silently introducing this set. Practicing what I would say and how, what inflections, when I would make eye contact with the audience. I used to do this with Trail Mix and BLOODCUP, starting off sets with a kind of tone and language that I hoped would carry us into our sets.

I haven't improvised on a stage since May 15th, the night before I left San Diego in a moving truck with my brother. That's six months ago now, almost to the day. I moved to Ohio to live and recover from a rather traumatic life change -- my wife broke up with me in January after 3+ years together, and less than a year as a wedded couple. I stayed at my brother's place for about 6 weeks, then had to leave that place after another traumatic life change. I had started to date someone in San Diego about a month before I left, both of us thinking it was going to be a nice way to spend a few weeks. But, as can happen, we found that we really (really, really) enjoyed one another's brains and manners and points-of-view, so she decided to come visit me in Ohio.

(( "I've never seen lightning bugs in person," is what she said. "I can help you with that problem," is what I told her. ))

I wasn't yet properly divorced, not that anyone in Ohio had asked me about that specifically, and the evening before her arrival I was told that it was inappropriate to have a romantic partner stay in the same room and in the same bed as me. I was welcome to continue to stay, of course, but she would need to find an alternate arrangement.

I moved my stuff out the following morning, and into my parents' house. Into my own teenage bedroom, to be precise. There were hurt feelings all around I think, and I don't know that I've properly recovered myself. I felt like -- I literally said the words out loud, in a whisper, alone in a room -- They don't have my back.

This was the thing Book Club would say to each other before going out to improvise our monthly show. I've got your back.

Except one member of our group, who would, ironically, humorously, say Watch your back.

It always put my hackles up. I didn't know how to express why this was so, and I doubted by own instincts about it. I needed to lighten up, is what I told myself. That was just how he was, and in saying the one thing he actually meant the other.

I'm not sure if I believe that now, several months on. I think he was saying the thing that he meant.

Before breaking up -- heck, before getting married -- when my wife and I would argue she would often, regularly tell me that she didn't think she could be the partner I wanted her to be. This would always upset me, and it derailed anything else I was thinking of. It would make me so mad because I thought it meant she was abandoning ship, that we could no longer even discuss the issue at hand, whatever it might be, because now we were suddenly in Should we break up or not? mode.

But after actually breaking up, it occurred to me -- like it should have all along -- that I should just listen to people when they say something. When someone declares, simply and straightforwardly, what they think and feel, you should just trust that person and what they are saying.

(( I'm not saying the end of our relationship was a failure on her part or as my partner -- what I mean is, she was saying very simply "I do not want to be your partner," and I was refusing to hear that. ))

I have moved around a lot as a grown-up. Cincinnati to Chicago to San Francisco to Ohio to Los Angeles to Vermont to Baltimore to San Diego to Ohio to Thailand. I have lived in any one of those places for anything from 6 months to 4 years, and I have made friends and social circles in all of them. My social network in San Diego was by far the biggest, and it felt the deepest. I was going onstage regularly with other people, not knowing what was about to happen, trusting that we were making art together.

I've got your back is what I told them, They've got my back is how I felt in return.

What is the idea that I'm circling right now? I'm not entirely sure. Some writers write with a thesis statement in mind, but I've always written with the need to figure out as I went along exactly what I was talking about.

I know that this entry started because I was writing an email to a new improv friend I made when I moved back to Ohio. He had also just moved there, from Baltimore, where I first took improv classes. I didn't know him there, but we had friends in common. The improv scene in Ohio was -- well. I dunno what it was, or what it is. I went to a few jams, I went to a show. It felt like -- I just wrote this in the email to my friend, about 45 minutes ago -- it felt like going on a date with someone when I was clearly not over my last relationship.

When I started going to improv shows in San Diego, I saw groups and players and I thought, There are no teams where I see a Matt-shaped hole. So I took classes, and it was only after having several scenes with my classmate Arbora that felt really good that felt like icebergs with more under the surface than was visible that I suggested putting our own team together. That turned into Trail Mix. With Trail Mix I felt like I was working with friends and fellow travelers*, and like we were growing and learning and making something together.

(( *"fellow travelers" is a whole other improv-related blog entry someday. ))

Being in Trail Mix and taking classes led me to Book Club, where I always felt like I was running and trying to keep up. That's not a bad thing! It was meant I was doing work that scared me. I probably failed more than I succeeded, but I learned a lot and I got to improvise with, objectively, better improvisors, better actors, and better performers than me. If you can stand a regular dose of humility and humiliation, that's not a bad masterclass in improv. Book Club led me to BLOODCUP, which started as a wouldn't it be funny if... kind of joke about an improv group, and led to the feeling that I was doing a thing, with people I cared for deeply, that would not have existed if I hadn't been in the room.

That's not to disparage Trail Mix or Book Club, it's just to say -- nobody every said to me, about Trail Mix doing monoscene or even about outright being in Book Club, that any of it was a bad idea. Even if it wasn't everyone's cup of tea, those were groups that were someone's cup of tea. BLOODCUP was a group that people actually told me was a pretty bad idea. I don't think anyone not a member of BLOODCUP ever expressed to me that they liked what we were doing. But goddamn, every time we played a BLOODCUP set, I went offstage feeling aLIVE. I felt like, holy shit, I do not understand what just happened, but I loved it.

I feel that way about the novel I wrote, and I feel that way about my weirdo improv team that performed like 3 shows ever.

What I'm saying is, peeking into the Cincinnati improv scene, I was just flat-out not ready to a) break into it, b) help build up what is a young and growing scene, or c) do the legwork necessary to make new friends in it.

I've got your back was a promise still echoing in my head. It wasn't something I wanted to hear from anyone else yet, because I didn't feel capable of believing it.

I texted my friend + BLOODCUP partner Keith, after going to a Cincinnati show, that I was quitting improv forever. It was a joke, but also not a joke? I think I was trying out the idea. But it wasn't about improv. It was about feeling lost and hurt and intimidated by trying again after falling down.

"A single wave sinks your boat," is what he said in return.

I've thought about that a lot. I think it's true -- I think it's my first impulse a lot of the time, at least. At least in the recovery mode I spent a lot of this year in, I was looking for any excuse to take No for an answer, almost all of the time.

I used to go to Book Club practices practicing speeches in my head. I was going to go through with this practice, I would tell myself, and then announce at the end that I was quitting. The feeling of trying and striving and coming up short -- a lot! -- was unpleasant and embarrassing. But I never went through with that impulse, largely because I just enjoyed being with those people so damn much.

In the months between getting married and then not being married, I would have dreams that my wife got a new job and told me we were moving to Minneapolis. Minneapolis was where we'd intended to move after leaving Baltimore, to follow my desire to go back to the midwest. She got a job offer in San Diego 2 weeks before we were set to embark, and we switched gears. In my dream, I was devastated at having to leave San Diego. I never intended to go there, but once there I never wanted to leave. I would wake up and tell her about the dream -- I had it 3 or 4 or half a dozen times -- and I told her I didn't want to go.  

"No one is going to make you," she said, both of us awake.

I made my own dream come true.

I don't know if a wave sank my boat, or if I just jumped overboard.

I don't feel I've quit improvising, though I haven't done it in practice or performance for six months. But I think I've been very fearful of asking anyone, or expecting anyone, to have my back, onstage or off.

I don't read a lot of improv blogs (or newsletters), but a San Diego improv acquaintance posted this one today, and I read it, and I keep thinking it over. Its thesis is to pick one team and be great on it, instead of being just okay on five. I guess that's good advice, but it's not why it sticks in my head. The single line I keep thinking about is, Form a group with people you dig seeing and hanging out with. That's why and how I started Trail Mix with Arbora and it's why and how I started BLOODCUP with Terri and Keith.

I think I kind of forgot about that. I didn't start improvising onstage because I felt an undeniable draw to the artform. I mean, I totally dig the artform! But I did it as an excuse to hang out with and play with people I really liked and trusted, and who trusted me back.

When it doesn't feel like that -- for all sorts of reasons, some of them outside of me and some of them in my own head and heart -- I haven't gone onstage.

We are BLOODCUP. We are a mirror. You are BLOODCUP. Can I get a suggestion of something you are afraid of?

How I Spent My Summer Vacation

• I dressed in black and performed gut-based improv with #BLOODCUP
• I drove across the country with my brother
• (California to Arizona to New Mexico to Texas to Arkansas to Tennessee to Kentucky to Ohio)
• We saw Mad Max in Arkansas
• We stopped at a lot of comic book stores and bought $1 comics
• He had to get a comic book box to keep all of his new comics in
• I stuffed mine in a backpack.
• We stopped at Graceland and wrote on the wall

• I went to Origins with the Diplomancers
• I played a pro-wrestling RPG
• I played a Jane Austen-style romance RPG
• I won the rake's hand by making him a frank business proposition, even though my younger sister was truly in love with him
• But he was a rake! It was partly for her protection
• I went to Chicago for a few days
• I talked to Annie in places where I used to go with Annie
• I rode my bike for Ohio miles
• Lots of people asked me why I was riding my bike
• I went running, a lot
• Lots of people yelled at me/flipped me off/swerved their cars toward me
• Chainé came to visit
• We went to green parts of Ohio, we went to Kentucky
• We went to Gatlinburg
• We went to Nashville
• We went dancing so hard in Nashville she lost a plug
• We made prints at Hatch
• We drove north again
• We rode roller coasters
• We built a partnership on affection, mutual respect, and murder
• We watched Twin Peaks from start to finish

•  I got back to work
• I spied on Ohioans doing improv
• I read books about travelers
• I made plans to travel
• I had Facebook fights
• Oh, I almost forgot something!
• That is legitimately true, but it was probably the biggest thing that happened this summer
• I can't say I was kicked out of any place
• But I was basically kicked out of a home + refuge 
• Made to feel ashamed and unworthy and sinful
• It's -- look, I'm not trying to start a fight here -- but it was bullshit
• I think it will fundamentally shape my Ohio relationships from now on
• I think if you build walls and create distance between yourself and others, you are doing it wrong
• Life, I mean
• and loving people
• and loving your family
• I don't mean to create distance
• But I'm not really ready to be the one to bridge the gap, you know? 
• For some reason I thought this was something David Milch said, but it looks like it's something Paul F. Davis said? I don't know who that is:
• "Go where you are celebrated, not merely tolerated."

• I will say it again: "Go where you are celebrated, not merely tolerated."
• I read interviews with Stephen Colbert that were really moving.
• I watched the first episode of his new show, and it was not moving.
• He said, "I love the thing that I most wish hadn't happened"
• I finished/filled up my Hobbit journal
• I started a new journal, untouched by the west coast or the east
•  I cleaned out my parents' basement
• I traded away my Nintendo games
• I wrote about some comics, but it was frustrating
• I came to terms with probably not writing that Friday Night Lights/relationship piece
• I might write it anyway, because holy smokes it will haunt me otherwise
• I bet it's how Axl felt about Chinese Democracy
• Just get it out there, you know? 
• I listened to the new-new Prince record, which is half good
• I listened to the new Carly Rae Jepsen record, which is all good
• I listened to a lot of Whiskeytown again! Crap they were a good band
• I guess they were more of a duo
• Being in improv groups has taught me about band dynamics
• Sometimes it's about talented people getting together, but mostly it's about personalities
• I bet being in the Rolling Stones is depressing
• Okay, maybe not the Rolling Stones but probably like Van Halen
• When it's a business arrangement, but it used to be a band
• Like you used to be friends with those guys, you know?
• And now there are friends, or ex-friends, not in the band anymore
• And Michael Anthony lives somewhere these days, and he probably opens the paper once a year and sees that Van Halen is coming to town and he's got to be like, "Huh!" 
• Or maybe he is touring with Chickenfoot or something. I hope so.
• Do not stay where you are merely tolerated 

That is some straight-up good advice.